Carried loaded, so the seams are the product

Log bags, compared on seams, load and internal length

A log carrier is taken to the woodshed empty and comes back holding twenty kilograms, which is the entire test. Three things decide whether it survives it. The seams — double-stitched and bar-tacked at the handle roots is the construction that lasts; a single row of stitching at the handle is where every failed bag fails. The handle construction follows: webbing that runs all the way under the base carries the load in the fabric rather than in the stitching, and the listings that show that continuous strap are showing the difference. The stated load in kilograms, published by about half of sellers, is the honest headline. Then the measurement people forget until the first trip: the internal length, which has to exceed the log length — a bag that takes 33 cm logs will not take 50 cm ones however wide it is. The material is canvas, waxed cotton, heavy polyester or leather-trimmed jute, and the practical difference is whether it can be left outside and whether it can be wiped. Finally the design question that separates a carrier from a hold-all: whether it stands up when filled and can be used as a hearthside basket, or collapses and is only a means of transport. We compare dimensions, volume, load rating, material, fabric weight, handles, floor and storage.

These parts, set out figure by figure

1. 

   DELAESI Large Foldable Firewood Carrier

   A closed Oxford carrier with padded handles that folds flat when it is not in use — the cheapest on this shelf.

   Dimensions

   Fully closed, stated so no wood debris falls out · Not published

   Volume

   The maker does not state it.

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   Hard-wearing Oxford, stated to protect against damp and dirt · Reinforced, stated

   Fabric weight

   The maker does not state it.

   Handles

   Wide and padded, stated for heavy logs

   Floor

   Solid, stated for shape retention under load

   Storage

   Folds flat when not in use

   Amazon reference

   B0H8N42GKR (one reference across 6 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   0737879021002

   • Padded handles, which is where a loaded log bag hurts
   • A closed form, so bark and splinters stay inside on the way through a house
   • No dimensions and no load rating, so nothing about its capacity is published

   Best for: A short carry from a shed to a stove, in something that folds away afterwards

   Check price on Amazon
2. 

   XINFULLWOL Waterproof Oxford Firewood Bag

   Waterproof Oxford sold specifically for keeping bark, splinters and snow out of the house — and offered as the tougher answer to a felt bag.

   Dimensions

   Fully closed, stated so no wood debris falls out · Not published

   Volume

   The maker does not state it.

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   Tear-resistant, waterproof Oxford, stated

   Fabric weight

   Not published

   Handles

   The maker does not state it.

   Floor

   Offered explicitly as the weatherproof alternative to a felt bag

   Storage

   Bark, splinters and snow, stated · Foldable

   Amazon reference

   B0FKZVJ3FG (one reference across 6 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   0749874336784

   • Names snow among what it keeps out, which matters for a bag used at an outdoor stack
   • Waterproof rather than water-repellent, which felt is not
   • Shares a feature sentence word for word with another listing in this family

   Best for: Fetching wood from an outdoor stack in winter, where the bag meets snow before the house does

   Check price on Amazon
3. 

   Relaxdays Felt Log Bag, 25 × 25 × 50 cm

   Five-millimetre felt with its dimensions actually published — soft enough to protect a floor, flexible enough to fold away.

   Dimensions

   Approximately H × W × D 25 × 25 × 50 cm

   Volume

   The maker does not state it.

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   Felt, with walls approximately 5 mm thick · The 5 mm walls are stated to be flexible and to adapt to the load · Available in several

   Fabric weight

   The maker does not state it.

   Handles

   A single robust carrying handle

   Floor

   Stated that the soft fabric spares the contents and the floor

   Storage

   Folds away, stated

   Amazon reference

   B078HJNB9W (one reference across 6 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   4052025961848

   • Publishes all three dimensions, which only three listings on this shelf do
   • Publishes the felt thickness, which two of the three felt bags here manage
   • A single handle rather than two, which concentrates the load and lets the bag swing

   Best for: A bag that lives beside the stove and goes as far as a dry shed and back

   Check price on Amazon
4. 

   BigDean Large Felt Log Bags, 30 L, Pack of Two

   Two thirty-litre felt bags in one order — the only multipack on this shelf, which is what a two-trip load actually needs.

   Dimensions

   Stated to be on the third product photograph rather than in the text

   Volume

   2 bags — the only multipack in this family · 30 litres each

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   High-quality tear-resistant felt, stated · Anthracite · Stated not to tear or fade

   Fabric weight

   The maker does not state it.

   Handles

   The maker does not state it.

   Floor

   Stated that the robust felt does not develop holes, so the floor stays free of dirt and dents

   Storage

   The maker does not state it.

   Amazon reference

   B0D31W4JDV (one reference across 5 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   4042366810646

   • Two bags for roughly the price of one elsewhere on this shelf
   • Publishes a volume, which four listings in this family do not
   • The dimensions are only on a photograph, not in the published text

   Best for: A household that fetches wood twice — one bag filling while the other empties

   Check price on Amazon
5. 

   Milduall Extra Large Felt Log Bag, 63 L

   The only bag on this shelf with a published load — up to 75 kg — at sixty-three litres, with a side pocket for the lighter.

   Dimensions

   53 × 40 × 30 cm

   Volume

   63 litres

   Load rating

   Up to 75 kg, stated — the only load figure in this family

   Material

   Polyester felt, 5 mm thick · A side pocket, stated for a lighter, phone, coins or tools

   Fabric weight

   The maker does not state it.

   Handles

   Two strong handles

   Floor

   Stated that the soft felt protects the floor from hard and sharp objects

   Storage

   Folds flat

   Amazon reference

   B0BB6CXB2T (one reference across 5 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   0761026966120

   • The only listing in this family to publish a load capacity
   • Publishes volume, dimensions and felt thickness together — the fullest specification on this shelf
   • Seventy-five kilograms is far more than anybody will carry, so the figure describes the bag rather than the trip

   Best for: One large load in from a dry store, carried two-handed and emptied at the hearth

   Check price on Amazon
6. 

   Esschert Design Firewood Carrying Bag

   A branded carrier with three published lines, and no material, no size and no capacity between them — robust is the whole statement.

   Dimensions

   Not published

   Volume

   Not published

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   GT22 · Not named — robust material is the whole statement · Not described

   Fabric weight

   The maker does not state it.

   Handles

   Not described

   Floor

   The maker does not state it.

   Storage

   Three: branded goods from the maker, universally usable, robust material

   Amazon reference

   B000ZGUW9I (one reference across 6 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   0225781773084

   • Carries a manufacturer reference, which suggests a catalogue behind it
   • From an established garden accessories brand rather than an unnamed seller
   • Three published features, none of which is a specification

   Best for: A buyer who already knows this maker’s range and is reordering by reference

   Check price on Amazon
7. 

   BONTHEE Waxed Canvas Log Carrier, 63 × 25 × 43 cm

   Waxed canvas that stands up on its own when empty — the only freestanding bag here, and the only one to publish its own weight.

   Dimensions

   63 × 25 × 43 cm

   Volume

   The maker does not state it.

   Load rating

   Not published

   Material

   Waxed canvas, stated waterproof, with reinforced seams · Khaki

   Fabric weight

   1 kg — the only bag weight published in this family

   Handles

   Two sturdy handles of hard-wearing material

   Floor

   Freestanding, stated — it stands up empty

   Storage

   Firewood, garden waste, or as a roomy storage bag

   Amazon reference

   B0FL6WRXQZ (one reference across 6 Amazon marketplaces)

   EAN

   4262472680876

   • Stands up on its own, so it can be loaded with two hands and left standing beside a stove
   • Publishes its own weight, which nothing else in this family does
   • The most expensive bag on this shelf by a wide margin

   Best for: A carrier that lives beside the stove standing up, and goes out in the wet without complaint

   Check price on Amazon